Ca$hing Out with VTG — Live every Wednesday at 5:30 PM EST on 103.9 LI News RadioListen Live

Six Questions Every Investor Should Ask

Buying a Business

Six Questions Every Investor Should Ask

Vince Gebbia answers six critical due diligence questions — from evaluating earnings quality and founder dependency to understanding ownership dilution, celebrity partnerships, and exit waterfalls.

V
Vincent Gebbia
••8 min read
Six Questions Every Investor Should Ask

Six Questions Every Investor Should Ask Before Writing a Check

Before any deal closes, the right questions separate a smart investment from an expensive mistake. Here are six questions every investor should be asking — and the answers that guide how we think about them at VTG and Hedgestone.

1. How do you determine whether a company's reported earnings are sustainable and will survive the founder's departure?

That's a great question, because when we're buying a business, we're not just buying what it earned yesterday. We're buying its ability to generate income tomorrow.

The first thing I look at is the quality of the earnings.

We review three years of financial statements, tax returns, bank deposits, payroll, and operating expenses.

But here's where experience really matters.

I want to know how dependent that company is on its owner.

Is the owner responsible for 80% of the relationships? Does the owner personally generate all the sales? Are the employees capable of running the operation without that individual?

Because if the founder leaves and the revenue disappears, you haven't purchased a sustainable business. You've purchased yourself a job.

At Hedgestone and VTG, we focus on identifying businesses with strong management, repeat customers, recurring revenue, and systems that operate independently.

And if the owner is essential, we need to account for the cost of replacing that owner in the earnings.

My philosophy is simple: The best businesses aren't dependent on the owner showing up every morning. They have systems, people, and customers that keep the money flowing.

That's what creates real enterprise value.

2. How can an investor tell whether new funding will create profitable growth or simply cover losses until the next fundraising round?

There's a tremendous difference between investing money to grow a profitable company and investing money just to keep a struggling company alive.

When someone approaches me looking for capital, my first question is: What exactly is this money going to accomplish?

Are we purchasing equipment that increases production? Opening another profitable location? Hiring salespeople who can generate additional revenue?

Or are we simply paying yesterday's bills?

I want to see a business plan with measurable results.

For example, if we're investing $500,000, show me how that investment increases revenue, what additional profit it generates, and when the company expects to produce positive cash flow.

I also look at how much cash the business is burning every month and how long the new funding will last.

A company that's constantly raising money without improving its economics can become a dangerous investment.

Here's my rule: Capital should create value, not simply postpone failure.

At VTG, we believe investors should understand exactly where their money is going and how that capital can ultimately produce a return.

3. How do you test whether a business is fairly valued, or priced as though its best-case future has already happened?

This is one of my favorite questions because valuation is where a lot of deals either make sense or fall apart.

I always tell buyers: Don't fall in love with the business. Fall in love with the numbers.

When we value a company, we look at actual cash flow, EBITDA, comparable transactions, industry multiples, and the company's growth potential.

Let's say a business is generating $1 million in EBITDA and the market supports a five-times multiple. That suggests a value of approximately $5 million, before considering adjustments such as debt, excess cash, and other deal-specific factors.

Now, if the seller wants $10 million because they believe the company will double in size over the next three years, that's a different conversation. You're being asked to pay today for growth that hasn't happened yet.

I always evaluate three scenarios: What happens if the company grows? What happens if it stays flat? And what happens if revenue declines? Can the investment still make sense under realistic assumptions?

One of the biggest mistakes investors make is paying tomorrow's price for today's business.

The goal isn't just to buy a great company. It's to buy a great company at a price that gives you the opportunity to make money.

4. Which ownership and financing terms could dilute an investor's stake or give other investors stronger rights?

This is where investors really need to pay attention to the fine print.

A lot of people get excited when somebody tells them they're receiving 10% ownership in a company. But my question is: Ten percent of what, and under what conditions?

Because not all ownership interests are created equal.

You need to understand whether the company can issue additional shares or ownership interests, whether future fundraising can dilute your percentage, and whether other investors have preferred rights.

For example, let's say you own 10% of a company. If the company raises additional capital by issuing new equity and you don't participate, your ownership could decrease.

You also need to understand liquidation preferences, voting rights, convertible debt, and whether certain investors receive their money back before you receive anything.

That's why I always encourage investors to review the operating agreement, capitalization table, and financing documents with qualified legal and financial professionals.

Remember this: Your ownership percentage is important, but your ownership rights can be even more important.

It's not just about getting into a deal. It's about understanding what you actually own and how you eventually get paid.

5. How do you assess the actual business value of a celebrity relationship, and what happens if that relationship ends?

Celebrity relationships can be incredibly valuable, but investors need to separate publicity from profitability.

Just because someone famous is associated with a company doesn't automatically make it a great investment.

The first question I ask is: What measurable economic value is that celebrity actually bringing to the business?

Are they generating sales? Bringing in customers? Increasing brand awareness? Creating distribution opportunities? And most importantly, can we measure those results?

For example, if a celebrity endorsement generates an additional $2 million in revenue, that's exciting. But we still need to understand how much profit that revenue produces and how much the company is paying for that relationship.

Then we look at the contract. How long is the agreement? Is it exclusive? Can the celebrity walk away? Does the company have the right to continue using their image?

And here's the biggest question: If that celebrity disappears tomorrow, does the business still have value?

Because at the end of the day, celebrity influence can open doors, but sustainable profits, loyal customers, and strong management are what create lasting enterprise value.

I would rather invest in a profitable business with a celebrity partnership than a celebrity partnership trying to become a profitable business.

6. After debt, fees, and investors who get paid first, how do you calculate what your own stake could actually receive from a sale?

This is probably one of the most important questions any investor can ask.

Because there's a big difference between what a company sells for and what an investor actually puts in their pocket.

Let's use a simple example. Suppose a company sells for $10 million. Everybody gets excited because they hear that $10 million number.

But let's say the company has $3 million in debt and another $500,000 in transaction expenses. Now we're down to approximately $6.5 million available for the equity holders, assuming no other adjustments.

And if there are preferred investors who must receive $2 million first, that leaves $4.5 million for the remaining owners. If you own 10% of that remaining equity, your share could be approximately $450,000 before taxes, depending on the ownership agreements.

That's why we create what's called an exit waterfall — it shows exactly how the money flows when a business is sold, who gets paid first, and what each investor ultimately receives.

At Hedgestone and VTG, we focus on understanding the entire transaction, not just the headline purchase price.

My philosophy is simple: It's not what the company sells for that matters most. It's what you actually walk away with.

And that number needs to be understood before you make the investment.

The Bottom Line

Building wealth isn't just about making money. It's about making intelligent decisions with the money you've earned.

Whether you're buying a business, investing in commercial real estate, acquiring a franchise, or preparing to sell a company you've spent years building, you need the right information, the right people, and the right strategy.

Relationships create opportunities — but knowledge and execution turn those opportunities into wealth.

Ready to explore a business acquisition or investment opportunity? Schedule a free consultation with the VTG team.

Explore Topics

#due diligence#business acquisition#investing#business valuation#EBITDA#exit waterfall#business broker Long Island#buying a business#enterprise value
V

Written by

Vincent Gebbia

Content creator and writer sharing insights and stories.

HedgeStone — The Largest Exclusive Business Marketplace in America. America Is For Sale. $4,997 value, now only $79. Join Now & Get First Look Access at VTGBusinessAdvisors.com